SEO

How to Tell If Your SEO Agency Is Actually Doing Anything

Published by
Adrian Newman

Here’s a monthly SEO report a lot of business owners will recognize.

“Rankings up 14 positions! Impressions up 32%! 187 keywords now ranking!” Green arrows everywhere. A nice chart going up and to the right.

But your phone isn’t ringing any more than it did last year.

While that report might be completely accurate, it might also be telling you almost nothing. The problem with SEO is that the work is invisible.

So, this post isn’t about whether SEO works. It does—when it’s done properly. It’s about how a business owner who isn’t an SEO expert can tell whether the money they’re spending every month is actually buying anything.

What a Monthly SEO Report Should Actually Show

A useful report answers four questions. If your report doesn’t answer all four, ask for them.

  1. What did the SEO company do? This is a specific list of work completed, with links. For instance: “Rewrote the furnace repair page (link),” “Fixed 12 broken links,” “Published two blog posts (links),” or “Updated the services list in your Google Business Profile.” Not “ongoing optimization.” Ongoing optimization is not a thing you can check.
  2. Did it bring in business? This includes calls, form submissions, and quote requests from search. It also includes calls, website clicks, and direction requests from your Google Business Profile. Ideally, the report will list how many of those turned into jobs. This usually requires your input, so expect your agency to ask you.
  3. Are we more visible for the searches that matter? These are rankings and clicks for a short list of searches that actually bring customers, like “furnace repair Vaughan,” not 187 keywords nobody will ever type. Clicks from Google Search Console for searches that don’t include your business name are especially useful because they show new people finding you.
  4. What’s next, and why? This is the plan for next month and the reasoning behind it. A good agency can explain its priorities in plain English.
NUMBERS THAT LOOK GOOD BUT OFTEN MEAN LITTLE
  • Impressions: Your site appeared in search results. Nobody had to see it, let alone click.
  • Number of Keywords Ranking: Ranking at position #74 for 150 terms adds up to a big number but generates zero customers.
  • Third-Party Scores: Metrics like “Domain Authority” are estimates provided by SEO tool companies, not metrics Google uses for ranking.
  • Traffic Without Context: Visitors from another country reading an outdated blog post are unlikely to call your plumbing business.
None of these are lies. They’re just not the scoreboard. Calls and jobs are the scoreboard.

What Google Tells You to Watch For

Google publishes a page called “Do you need an SEO?” for business owners thinking about hiring one. Most business owners have never read it. They should.

According to Google:

  • No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.
  • If they guarantee that their changes will give you first place in search results, find someone else.
  • Beware of SEOs that claim to guarantee rankings or allege a “special relationship” with Google. There is no priority submit for Google.
  • Be careful if a company is secretive or won’t clearly explain what they intend to do.
  • Results typically take “from four months to a year” from when changes begin.

Another warning sign is an SEO that guarantees ranking, but only on obscure, long keyword phrases you would get anyway. For instance, an agency can “guarantee” page one for “emergency 24-hour water heater repair near Keele and Rutherford” because almost nobody searches it and almost nobody competes for it. It looks like a win in the report, but it brings in nothing.

Red Flags That Should Make You Ask Hard Questions

  • They own your accounts. Your Google Business Profile, Search Console, Google Analytics, or domain are under the agency’s login, not yours.
  • They won’t say what they changed. Google is clear that an SEO should be willing to explain the changes they make. “It’s proprietary” is not an answer.
  • The report is the same every month. Same template, same comments, numbers swapped. Nobody’s thinking about your business. Nobody asks you anything. They don’t know your best services, your service area, or which jobs you actually want more of.
  • “We’ll build you 500 backlinks.” Buying links in bulk is the kind of thing Google’s spam policies target. It can do real damage.
  • Only rankings, never leads. If every conversation is about positions and none is about calls, the agency is measuring what’s easy, not what matters.

So, Who Should Own What?

This is very important: You should own every account, and your agency should just have access. This includes:

  • Your domain name (the yourbusiness.com address), registered in your name.
  • Your website hosting and the website’s admin login.
  • Your Google Business Profile, with you as owner and the agency added as a manager.
  • Google Search Console and Google Analytics, owned by you, with the agency added as a user.
  • Your Google Ads account, if you run ads.

Here’s a quick gut check you can do today: if you parted ways with your agency tomorrow, what would you lose? If the answer is “my website,” “my reviews,” or “I don’t know,” fix that first.

Google’s own guidance points the same way: when you’re evaluating an SEO, give them read-only access to Search Console, not the keys to everything.

Five Questions to Ask on Your Next Call

You don’t need to understand SEO to ask these questions. You only need to notice whether the answers are specific.

  • “What did you change on my site last month? Can you show me?” A good answer has links. A bad answer has adjectives.
    • “How many leads came from Google search and my Google Business Profile?” If they don’t know, ask how they can find out.
    • “Which ten searches matter most for my business, and where do I stand on each?” This shows whether they understand what you sell.
    • “What are you doing about AI search?” Google says optimizing for AI is still SEO, so the answer should be about clear pages, your Business Profile, and your reputation, not a separate bag of tricks.
    • “What’s the plan for the next 90 days, and what would make you change it?” You’re listening for priorities and reasons, not a script.

    Be Fair: What’s Reasonable to Expect

    None of this means firing your agency because one month was flat. SEO doesn’t work like ads, where you switch it on and clicks show up tomorrow.

    Google says results typically take four months to a year. The early months are often fixes and foundations you won’t feel right away. Some months are quiet. That’s normal.

    And some things no agency can control. Your business’s distance from the person searching is a big part of who shows up on the Google map, and no amount of SEO moves your address.

    What’s not normal is a long stretch where you can’t see the work, can’t connect it to leads, and can’t get a straight answer about either. Quiet results with visible work is patience. Quiet results with invisible work is a problem.

    When to Give It Time, and When to Walk Away

    Give it time if the work is visible, the reports are honest about what’s not moving yet, and the plan makes sense when they explain it.

    Walk away if you can’t get access to your own accounts, they promised rankings they couldn’t possibly guarantee, or after six months nobody can tell you what’s been done. Before you leave, make sure every account is transferred into your name.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How do I know if my SEO agency is doing anything?

    Ask for a monthly list of specific work completed, with links you can check, and for results tied to your business, such as calls, form submissions, and Google Business Profile actions. If your agency can’t show what changed or connect its work to leads over several months, that’s a warning sign.

    What should be in a monthly SEO report?

    A useful SEO report shows the work completed with links, leads from search and your Google Business Profile, visibility for a short list of searches that matter to your business, and the plan for next month. Impressions and keyword count alone don’t show whether SEO is bringing in customers.

    How long should SEO take to show results?

    Google’s guidance says it typically takes four months to a year from when changes begin before you start to see the benefits. Early months often focus on fixes and foundations, so progress should be measured by visible work first and business results over time.

    Can an SEO agency guarantee first place on Google?

    No. Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google and advises finding someone else if an SEO guarantees first place. Some agencies guarantee rankings for obscure phrases that few people search, which Google lists as a warning sign.

    Should my SEO agency own my Google accounts?

    No. You should own your domain, website, Google Business Profile, Google Search Console, Google Analytics, and Google Ads accounts. Your agency should be added as a user or manager, so you keep everything if you change agencies.

    Want a Second Opinion on Your SEO?

    At Numero Uno Web Solutions, we’re happy to look at what your current agency is doing and tell you honestly what we see, even if the answer is “they’re doing a good job, stick with them.” If you want a straight read on your SEO, get in touch.

    Recent Posts

    Your Service Pages Are Why You Don’t Rank (or Convert)

    Picture two roofers in the same city. Roofer A has one page called "Services." It… Read More

    2 weeks ago

    Google AI Mode and Local Search: What’s Actually Changing (and What Isn’t)

    Here are two ways the same person might look for an electrician. Search one: "electrician… Read More

    3 weeks ago

    Speed to Lead: The Leads You’re Already Losing After They Contact You

    Tuesday, 10:14 a.m. A homeowner's water heater quits. She searches, opens three plumbing websites, and… Read More

    4 weeks ago

    Why Most Small Business Google Ads Campaigns Waste Money (and How to Stop It)

    Here's how it usually goes. A kitchen renovator sets up a Google Ads campaign one… Read More

    1 month ago

    The 3 A’s of Digital Marketing for Small Businesses

    Most small business owners aren't short on marketing advice. They're drowning in it. Post on… Read More

    1 month ago

    The Psychology Behind Website Trust: 6 Signals That Turn Website Visitors into Customers

    People decide whether they trust your website in five hundredths of a second. That's not… Read More

    2 months ago